ComicValue
ComicValue Editorial • Updated

What Does CGC 9.8 Mean? Grade, Labels and Value

Fictional ungraded comic beside a magnifier and blank condition notebook; no certified grade is shown.

CGC 9.8 means Near Mint/Mint (NM/M): a nearly perfect comic, not a flawless one. It is a condition opinion on CGC’s scale, not a dollar value or a forecast of what the comic will sell for. A 9.8 and a 9.6 can have different prices, but there is no fixed conversion between them.

This guide answers the specific 9.8 question. For the complete 25-entry reference, use our comic grading scale chart. If you are deciding whether to submit a raw book, the separate raw-versus-graded worksheet compares costs and uncertain outcomes.

Sources checked October 19, 2026. The comparison prices below are invented teaching examples, not recorded transactions. The original AI-generated hero is editorial artwork; the pictured comic has no assigned or certified grade.

What 9.8 means on the CGC scale

CGC’s published grading scale allows negligible manufacturing or handling defects at 9.8. Nearby grades are different condition categories, not percentages of a comic’s price or probabilities of resale:

GradeCGC termPractical interpretation
10.0Gem MintHighest category; no manufacturing or handling defects
9.9MintVery minor manufacturing defect, without handling defects
9.8NM/MNearly perfect; negligible defects can remain
9.6NM+Very well preserved, with several minor defects
9.4NMMinor wear and small manufacturing or handling defects

The scale starts at 0.5, not 0.1. Also, 9.0 is Very Fine/Near Mint (VF/NM), not simply Very Fine. Those distinctions matter when matching a seller’s abbreviation to a comparison copy. A 9.8 is below both 9.9 and 10.0; describing it as certified perfection sets the wrong expectation.

Do not use this short table as a self-grading formula. A professional assessment considers the actual book, including areas a front-cover photograph does not reveal. A new comic can have production or handling problems before you receive it; being newly purchased is not evidence of a particular grade.

Can a 9.8 have spine ticks or other small flaws?

The category allows negligible defects, but that does not establish a rule such as “one tick is acceptable” or “two ticks means 9.6.” Size, severity, location, the rest of the book and the grader’s assessment matter. A phone image may hide a crease in glare or fail to show an interior problem.

For research, make a condition record rather than promising a score:

  • Photograph the front and back in even light, without filters that disguise wear.
  • Describe what you see: for example, “small mark beside the upper staple,” not “guaranteed 9.8.”
  • Record whether the interior was checked and which areas remain uncertain.
  • Avoid forcing a fragile spine open or removing material to improve its appearance.
  • Seek experienced help if completeness, restoration or safe handling is in doubt.

These observations help you ask better questions. They cannot certify a grade. Nor should the fictional comic in this article’s artwork be used to judge which defects a grading service would accept.

Read the label, not just the large number

A matching 9.8 number does not make two sales interchangeable. CGC’s label guide distinguishes Universal certification from categories involving witnessed or authenticated signatures, qualifications, restoration and conservation. Read the category and notes before choosing comparable copies.

CheckWhy it changes the comparison
Series, issue, year and printingAn original edition and a facsimile may share cover artwork
Variant or distribution editionDifferent versions can attract different buyers
Numerical grade and page qualityA grade alone does not capture every displayed attribute
Label category and qualificationsSignature, restoration or missing-material details can make a sale unsuitable
Certification number and listing photosThe record and the actual item being offered should correspond

Use the official Verify CGC Certification tool to check the available record, and compare identifying details with the listing. If something does not match, stop and ask the seller or certification service for clarification. A valid number alone is not proof that every photograph, holder or seller claim is genuine.

CGC Grader Notes may add context. CGC says notes are discretionary, are not entered for every certified collectible and may not list every defect. Therefore, no notes does not mean no defects, and notes are not a complete substitute for examining photos and the item itself.

Compare 9.8 and 9.6 prices without inventing a premium

Build two separate groups of recent completed sales. Keep the same printing, variant, certification company, label category and other important attributes. Exclude raw copies, multi-book lots and active asking prices from a direct 9.8-versus-9.6 comparison.

Our eBay sold-price research guide explains the filters. eBay’s Product Research documentation says its research results include actual accepted Best Offer prices; a crossed-out public asking price should not be assumed to be the accepted amount. Check access terms and the available evidence rather than filling gaps with guessed prices.

Here is an entirely hypothetical comparison for one unspecified edition, with otherwise matched attributes and the same delivered-price basis in USD:

Fictional grade groupFictional matching totalsMedian
9.6$90, $100, $110$100
9.8$120, $140, $160$140

In that invented sample, the median difference is $40 and the ratio is 1.4×, calculated as $140 ÷ $100. It is not 3× simply because the labels differ by 0.2. Another issue, date range or edition could produce a different result, and three examples per group would still be a small sample.

For real research, save links, dates, sample counts, shipping basis and exclusion reasons. If one group has one old sale and the other has several recent sales, describe that imbalance. The result may be “not enough matching evidence,” not a precise premium. A ratio describes the observed sample; it is not a rule for pricing every copy or predicting the next transaction.

What population data can and cannot tell you

The CGC Population Report describes recorded graded submissions. Its own disclaimer says population figures are not an indicator of value or rarity and should not be relied on for a purchase or investment decision.

A reported count is not a census of every surviving raw comic, every other certification service’s work, or every owner willing to sell. Even a small number does not tell you whether enough buyers want that edition at the asking price. Record the report date and exact category if you use the data, and do not turn it into an invented “only this many exist” claim.

No issue-level population figures were retrieved for this article. The old version’s unsourced population and price examples have been removed rather than relabeled as current market evidence.

Should you pay to chase a 9.8?

Separate owning a certified copy from submitting an uncertified one. Buying an already-graded example lets you research the displayed grade, but you still need to examine the label, listing, seller and price. Submitting a raw copy adds costs and an uncertain result; its best possible sale price is not the only outcome to model.

Use the grading-cost guide for fee categories and the break-even worksheet to compare net proceeds after grading and selling expenses. Do not make a submission depend on achieving 9.8 without understanding what happens financially if it does not.

Pressing is not a guaranteed shortcut. CGC’s pressing guidance allows for no grade change, a lower grade and possible damage. Consider condition and purpose before any treatment; this is not a recommendation for a do-it-yourself procedure.

Where ComicValue fits in the research

ComicValue can be a mobile starting point for identification, collection organization and value research. Review the iOS listing or Android listing for current features, availability and purchase terms. Verify a suggested identity against the physical book and check important sold evidence independently.

Neither an app result nor this guide assigns a professional grade, guarantees a 9.8 outcome or establishes a future selling price. The useful result is a documented comparison: what the number means, which copies genuinely match, what evidence exists and what remains uncertain.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does CGC 9.8 mean?

CGC 9.8 is Near Mint/Mint (NM/M), a nearly perfect condition grade that can allow negligible handling or manufacturing defects. It is not Gem Mint 10.0 or a price guarantee.

Is a 9.8 comic flawless?

No. CGC's scale allows negligible defects at 9.8. A cover photograph or a count of spine ticks cannot establish the grade or the condition of interior pages.

How much more is 9.8 worth than 9.6?

There is no universal multiplier. Compare recent sales of the same issue, printing, variant, label category and page quality, keeping the two grades in separate groups.

Does a small population prove a comic is rare?

No. CGC's population report counts certified submissions, not every surviving copy or all available sellers. CGC cautions that population data is not an indicator of value or rarity.

Explore Key Comic Price Guides

Browse our master price guide directory for 250+ key issues.

Want to know what your collection is worth?

Start your comic identification and valuation research on mobile. Check editions, condition and comparable sales before relying on an estimate.